SPINE 1.2.24 - problems with unusual SNMP values?

[GGA]

I'm on the latest released Cacti/Spine 1.2.24.

I try to monitor the optical SFP RX/TX power from a Brocade ICX switch.
The returned values have a kind of unusual setup:

Code: Select all

snmpget -v2c -c xxx host .1.3.6.1.4.1.1991.1.1.3.3.10.1.4.17.1 -Ovqa
"-008.6806 dBm Normal"

There are double quotes and values and strings together.

I wrote a small snmp_queries XML but that only works during the realtime monitoring.

The default 5min monitoring just shows me a warning in cacti.log:

Code: Select all

2023-07-18 18:11:19 - SPINE: Poller[1] PID[78909] PT[139655334712896] WARNING: Invalid Response, Device[81] HT[1] DS[20783] SNMP: v2: <device>, dsname: snIfMonitoringTxPwr, oid: .1.3.6.1.4.1.1991.1.1.3.3.10.1.3.17.1, value: -001.9661 dBm Normal

Spine debugging gives me rather the same:

Code: Select all

/usr/local/spine/bin/spine --first=81 --last=81 -R -S -V 5
...
Total[0.1410] WARNING: Invalid Response, Device[81] HT[1] DS[20783] SNMP: v2: <device>, dsname: snIfMonitoringRxPwr, oid: .1.3.6.1.4.1.1991.1.1.3.3.10.1.4.17.1, value: -008.7127 dBm Normal
Total[0.1411] Device[81] HT[1] DS[20783] TT[86.08] SNMP: v2: <device>, dsname: snIfMonitoringRxPwr, oid: .1.3.6.1.4.1.1991.1.1.3.3.10.1.4.17.1, value: U
Total[0.1411] WARNING: Invalid Response, Device[81] HT[1] DS[20783] SNMP: v2: <device>, dsname: snIfMonitoringTxPwr, oid: .1.3.6.1.4.1.1991.1.1.3.3.10.1.3.17.1, value: -001.9661 dBm Normal
Total[0.1411] Device[81] HT[1] DS[20783] TT[86.10] SNMP: v2: <device>, dsname: snIfMonitoringTxPwr, oid: .1.3.6.1.4.1.1991.1.1.3.3.10.1.3.17.1, value: U

Also Data Source Troubleshooter sees issues with bad results.

troubleshooter.png (15.98 KiB) Viewed 1161 times

But why is realtime monitoring working? Does it anything different than general 5min polling with Spine?
Could there be something with the snmp_query XML? Well if so, would realtime monitoring work neither?

[GGA]

viewtopic.php?t=62724
This is maybe the same as we have.
In my case, cmd.php works but takes so much longer.

[Osiris]

Spine should have stripped those trailing values.

[Osiris]

You should log a bug on GitHub.

[GGA]

Done, https://github.com/Cacti/spine/issues/311

[Osiris]

Grab the latest 1.2.x branch. It's fixed there already.

[GGA]

Thank you Osiris and TheWitness, this seems to fix it with the latest 1.2.x branch.
But in my case, this version brings me a new problem and this could fit together.
My bind9 monitoring based on Script/Command stops working with the latest 1.2.x branch.
The input string

Code: Select all

<path_cacti>/scripts/bind-stats.sh <hostname>

leads to an error because of the wrong placed quotes:

Code: Select all

ERROR: Problem executing POPEN. File '/var/www/cacti/scripts/bind-stats.sh 'host'' does not exist or is not executable. 

[TheWitness]

Does the file exist and is it executable?

[TheWitness]

Maybe change to

Code: Select all

/bin/sh -c /blah.sh <hostname>

Instead.

[TheWitness]

Run spine at debug level for that host_id

Code: Select all

./spine -R -V5 -S -H host_id

[TheWitness]

Log that to github too. Include the output.

[GGA]

I will paste it to github.
The script is executable and it still works when I switch back to spine release 1.2.24:

latest 1.2.x branch

Code: Select all

Total[0.1978] The executable is '/usr/bin//var/www/cacti/scripts/bind-stats.sh' in '/var/www/cacti/scripts/bind-stats.sh 'HOST''
Total[0.1979] Device[3] ERROR: Problem executing POPEN.  File '/var/www/cacti/scripts/bind-stats.sh 'HOST'' does not exist or is not executable.

With spine release 1.2.24

Code: Select all

Total[0.2237] DEBUG: Device[3] DEBUG: The NIFTY POPEN returned the following File Descriptor 9
Total[0.2529] Device[3] HT[1] DS[595] TT[29.47] SCRIPT: /var/www/cacti/scripts/bind-stats.sh 'HOST', output: a:23726299 a6:1 aaaa:16733246 any:1572 cname:27042 mx:2257 naptr:42117 ns:5755 ptr:8034 soa:3460 spf:6 srv:934732 txt:19786 rsnx:749692 rsfail:76 rserr:7 rsipv4qs:1586174 rsipv4rr:1532849 rsmismatch: rsqr:1699338 rsqt:76206 rsrtt10:6476462 rsrtt100500:500206 rsrtt10100:2471797 rsrtt1600:577 rsrtt500800:4772 rsrtt8001600:979 sockopen:2435733 sockclosed:2435725 sockbf:189 consest:1584432 recverr:4364

[TheWitness]

I'm going to be fixing this today.

[TheWitness]

Should be fixed as of 5 minutes ago.

[GGA]

Cool, it is working now. Thank you for fixing this.